Les brings Tara home to his Brooklyn apartment after an obviously successful date. Things between them are just getting interesting when Les stumbles in to find a surprise party of his close friends, eager to celebrate his recent separation from his long-time partner, Sean. Unaware of Les' new-found interest in the opposite sex, his best friend Alison is caught more than slightly off-guard when she interrupts Les and Tara in a particularly vulnerable position. The rest of the evening is passed by the two friends facing up to some hard truths: Les grappling with this new voyage into bisexuality, and Alison trying to pin down the reason Les didn't think of her as an option. They tackle these issues with a blend of humor, tenderness and tequila. In the end, we see that sexuality and identity are just as undefinable as friendship and love.