Late Night Mystery Fun Show follows Petra and Damien, an duo who extort criminals for a living. After splitting up for the first time the pair go through a series of events that is sure to test them. Damien is sent on his first solo extortion, and meets Benjamin, an eccentric philosophical pyramid schemer. Petra on the other hand finally lets herself be vulnerable and goes on a date with Noah. After revealing to him a secret package that had been haunting her, Noah helps her find the truth. Late Night Mystery Fun Show is David McGorlick's honors year project and is a seedy, existential, taut work of comedy.